Sidebar Header

Sidebar Header

Sidebar Header

Top 10 Hottest Celebrity “Girls Next Door”…EVER

Mr. Mister | Allyson Hannigan, Jenna Fisher, Laura Prepon, Lists, Other Celebrities | Monday, 01 October 2007

You all know the “Girl Next Door”. She doesn’t look like Pamela Anderson in her prime, she looks like a real woman. The kind of girl you could take home to mom, but still be blown away with just how smokin’ hot she is.

This list is dedicated to ALL the super-hot Girl’s Next Door. There have been so many of them over the years on our TVs and in movies, that it’s almost impossible to pick 10 that everyone can agree on…but we did it anyway!

So, without further adieu, here are the Top 10 Hottest Celebrity “Girls Next Door” – EVER!

10. Maureen McCormick – “Marsha Brady”


Sure, those of you under 20 may not have spent much time staring at Marsha – but even those of you in you 25 and up remember watching Marsha Brady in re-runs. Maureen McCormick was the quintessential Girl Next Door in her day, and when we found out there was a new tell-all book coming out that reveals she had a lesbian fling with on-screen sister Jan? Well – that sent her over the top.”Marsha, Marsha, Marsha” indeed.

09. Allyson Hannigan

Allyson isn’t known for just one role anymore, but she first entered our hearts as Willow on “Buffy the Vampire Slayer”. She entered the minds of every read blooded American male when she utterd “…this one time, at band camp…”, and now we find ourselves hoping she’ll “cross over” again with that dark haired chick on “How I Met Your Mother”.

Through it all, Allyson has had that cute, sexy smile, and a playful demeanor that scream super hot Girl Next Door…

08. Dawn Wells – Mary Anne from “Gilligan’s Island

Everyone knew that Ginger was a ho-bag…but sweet, beautiful Mary Anne was a super hot Girl Next Bungalo. From her sweet smile, to her beautiful features, to her ability to mail Bob Denver pot through the US Postal Service – yes, sweet Mary Anne had it all.

07. Tiffany Amber Thiessen – “Kelly Kapowski”

Before the plastic surgery, Tiffany Amber Thiessen was THE Girl Next Door hottie for every male born between 1978 and 1983. Seriously – If you can show me a guy born in that time frame that didn’t have at least a slight crush on Ms. Kapowski here, I’ll show you a sad, sad, shell of a man.

06. Sally Field

What!?!?? Isn’t she that old lady that got cut off at the Emmy’s?Well – yes, but she wasn’t always a grandmother you know – and back in her day she was cute as a button. I mean, seriously, look at her…this pic is from back in her “Gidget” days – now, go rent, buy, or find some place to download “Smokey and the Bandit” – you can’t tell me she’s not a hot little cutie pie….you just can’t….

05. Danica McKellar – Winnie Cooper “The Wonder Years”

Again – it goes back to kids of a certain age – but if you were watching “The Wonder Years” in the 80s, you shared Kevin Arnold’s life long crush with the girl next door…Winnie Cooper. These days she’s guest starring on “How I Met Your Mother”, and has filmed a TV series called “Inspector Mom” where she plays a soccer mom/detective – which has yet to air on any network – but we’ll always…ALWAYS…have a place in our hearts for Winnie Cooper.


04. Kari Byron – Mythbusters

She looks like a super hot “Girl Next Door” – but this time – she’s a SCIENTIST! Oh yes – hot AND smart…wait – can that work together?


03. Laura Prepon – Donna “That 70’s Show”

For the better part of a decade we watched the hottest red head in the world live right next door to the lankiest geek that’s ever lived…and then he started banging her…and we though, “Dammit! Why can’t that be ME?!?!?” He was Eric – She was Donna – and they were totally awesome.Now, she’s playing a single mother on “October Road”, a night time soap that probably won’t last through season two. So she’s now she’s blond and a total MILF, but we’ll always remember her as one of the hottest Girl’s Next Door that’s ever graced our television sets.

02. Jennifer Aniston

She started out as a Friend, and has found her way into our homes in half a dozen movies since. Her haircut inspired a national trend, and the world fell in love with her just as much as Ross ever did.

01. Jenna Fisher – Pam Beasley “The Office”

She’s the ultimate “Girl Next Door” – and we’ve watched with baited breath as Pam and Jim have gone down the long journey to being together on “The Office”….and…just look at that picture – I mean – COME ON…that’s hot.Jenna Fisher is our raining queen of “Girl’s Next Door” hotness – and as far as I’m concerned – it’s going to take an act of the All Mighty to knock her off her throne.

So…that’s it – our Top 10. Agree? Disagree? Sound off in the comments below, and let us know who you think should be #1!

Popularity: 49% [?]

1,473 Comments